Standing Your Ground...on the Tennis Courts?

Last night I came across an interesting article out of Miami regarding a Stand Your Ground case involving a tennis instructor and a 5 year old student. Yes, that's right, the adult tennis instructor is invoking Stand Your Ground (SYG) immunity in a case where he is alleged to have hit the young boy with the boy's tennis racquet. As always, though, there is more to the story and an actually viable claim for SYG immunity.

According to the defendant, Osmailer Torres, and his attorney, Eduardo Pereira (whom I know and have worked with and consider a fine attorney), the boy had a history of "various violent altercations" against the other tennis students. In this situation, the boy was the "initial aggressor" who, after being separated from the other kids, lifted his racquet "in the air and was poised to strike again against the other students and Mr. Torres." 

In the process of taking away the child's tennis racquet, Torres hit the child causing a bruise on the right arm and a lump on the eyebrow. Torres and his attorney claim it was inadvertent as he tried to protect the other children, while the State Attroney's office claims video of the incident doesn't show the boy aggressively approaching any of the other students. 

Here's the nuance in SYG that you may not have seen before: the law allows a person to use force against another if that person reasonably believes the force "is necessary to defend himself or herself or another against" the imminent use of unlawful force. See, Fla. Stat. § 776.012(1). In other words, a person can use force in defending others against another attacking them. 

So while it may not seem reasonable that Torres defending himself from a 5 year old swinging a tennis racquet, it is certainly reasonable that he was defending other children from the actions of this boy and in the process of using force to remove the racquet from the boy's hands may have caused some injuries. According to Assistant State Attorney Gabriela Plasencia, however, the State doesn't believe Torres was acting under any imminent threat of danger to himself or others based on the video.

The case certainly changes once more of the facts are known and that the SYG law protects those who also defend others.  

The hearing on the SYG motion is set early next year before Judge Oscar Rodriguez-Fonts. It will be interesting to see what the happens at the hearing.

George C. Palaidis is a criminal defense and personal injury attorney practicing in Miami, Fort Lauderdale, and the South Florida region.